01 - Verified Facts

5707 Scenic Ave - Verified Facts

Property identity

• Address: 5707 Scenic Ave, Mexico, NY 13114
• County: Oswego County
• Tax Map ID: 134.10-02-12
• SWIS: 353401
• Property Class: 220 - 2 Family Residential
• Neighborhood Code: 34003 - Village Residential

Physical characteristics

From the county property description report:

• Living area: 2,184 sq ft
• Year built: 1900
• Effective year built: 1975
• Stories: 2
• Bedrooms: 5
• Bathrooms: 2 full
• Kitchens: 2
• Basement: Full
• Fireplaces: 0
• Central air: No
• Overall condition: Normal
• Overall grade: Average
• Building style: Old style

Site / lot

• Lot size: 108.95 x 198.5
• Approx. lot area: ~0.49 acres
• Agricultural district: No

Utilities

• Sewer: Public / commercial
• Water: Public / commercial
• Utilities: Gas & electric
• Heat type: Hot air
• Fuel: Natural gas

Current ownership

• Current owner: John R Alessio
• Most recent recorded sale date: 2024-09-03
• Most recent recorded sale price: $255,000
• Sale type: Arms length

Assessment / taxes

• 2025 land assessment: $17,400
• 2025 total assessment: $155,000
• 2025 full market value: $254,098
• 2025 county tax: $2,472.37
• 2025 school tax: $3,138.43
• 2025 total known taxes: $5,610.80
• 2026 county tax: $2,533.97

What is verified vs not

Verified

• The house exists and county records align with the address.
• It was purchased by Alessio in Sept 2024 for $255,000.
• It is assessed as a 2-family property with 2 kitchens.
• It has public water/sewer and natural gas.
• It is a 1900 house with effective year 1975.

Not yet verified

• Whether the house is formally the NRHP-listed Timothy Skinner House.
• Whether the current real-world use matches the 2-family tax classification.
• Whether any major work has been done recently.
• Whether there are title issues, liens, or flood concerns.